‚Jewish Heritage Community Resilience’

Interdependencies of Cultural Heritage and Resilience in Times of Crises, Wars and Disasters

2025-2028

Main Project

Disasters and conflicts pose a threat to both tangible and intangible cultural heritage, including traditional knowledge that is essential for the preservation of other forms of heritage. The loss of cultural heritage can have catastrophic societal consequences, including the erosion of fundamental constructs that shape identity, values, and perceptions of reality. Without adequate protection, cultural heritage is at risk of being irreparably damaged, with far-reaching implications for society as a whole.

Against this backdrop, the interdisciplinary research project explores the complex dynamics of threat, destruction, preservation, and protection of Jewish heritage in Israel, and how this heritage—despite various threats—contributes to social resilience, or more specifically, to “Jewish Heritage Community Resilience.” Central to the project is an investigation of the relationship between Jewish cultural heritage and resilience-building from diverse perspectives. A unifying element across all sub-projects is their focus on the preservation, sustainability, and safeguarding of Jewish heritage, taking into account both its tangible and intangible dimensions. In doing so, each aspect of the project analyzes the significance of heritage for cultural identity and the capacity for crisis management within Israeli society.

By integrating historical, sociological, musicological, and theological perspectives, the project enables a multifaceted examination of Jewish resilience, with a particular emphasis on: (1) how Jewish heritage—including naturally occurring archaeological degradation—can be preserved in the long term, and (2) how Jewish heritage in both Israel and the diaspora can sustainably contribute to the strengthening of communal resilience.

Kooperationspartner*innen und Assoziierte

Person, Institut, Hochschule

Person, Institut, Hochschule

Person, Institut, Hochschule

Institution, Ort

Institution, Ort

Institution, Ort

Principal Investigators

Prof. Dr. Sarah M. Ross

European Centre for Jewish Music

Hanover University of Drama, Music and Media (Germany)

Further Information

Prof Dr. Anselm Hagedorn

Professorship for Old Testament and Ancient Judaism

Institute of Protestant Theology

Osnabrück University (Germany)

Further Information

Dr. theol Florian Oepping

Chair of Old Testament and Ancient Judaism

Institute of Protestant Theology

Osnabrück University (Germany)

Further Information

Dr. Cordula Dittmer

Katastrophenforschungsstelle (KFS)

Institut für Geographische Wissenschaften

Freie Universität Berlin (Germany)

Weitere Informationen

Dr. Daniel F. Lorenz

Katastrophenforschungsstelle (KFS)

Institut für Geographische Wissenschaften

Freie Universität Berlin (Germany)

Further Information

Research Associates

Roy Albag

Chair of Old Testament and Ancient Judaism

Institute of Protestant Theology

Osnabrück University (Germany)

Samuel Weigel, M.A.

European Centre for Jewish Music

Hanover University of Drama, Music and Media (Germany)

Further Information

more…

Subprojects

Subproject 1: Preservation of Tangible Cultural Heritage vis-à-vis Cultural Sustainability (Prof. Dr. Anselm Hagedorn, Dr. Florian Oepping und Roy Albag)

This subproject investigates, from a theological-archaeological perspective, which strategies exist or can be developed for the preservation and presentation of Jewish cultural heritage, using the archaeological site of Tel Moẓa as a case study. The temple complex has undergone visible transformations over the centuries, not all of which can be physically preserved. The subproject aims to address this issue by developing a sustainable strategy that not only preserves the various historical phases of the temple complex, but also captures the life and ritual practices associated with it.

Starting from the material heritage, the subproject further examines which factors influence decisions regarding the preservation of cultural heritage in Israel. In doing so, it considers not only scholarly criteria but also the political interests that must not be overlooked. Particularly in the past, Israeli politics has been closely intertwined with archaeology, with the latter serving to reinforce state narratives and contribute to the construction of collective identity.

The reference to biblical scriptures also plays a decisive role in this context; however, it must be emphasized that these texts do not constitute objective historical records, but are inherently subjective narratives. Nonetheless, the Hebrew Bible is of central importance not only in relation to material cultural heritage but also in shaping community identity and strengthening “Jewish Heritage Community Resilience.”

The subproject explores the resilience strategies already present in the Old Testament and investigates how the loss of material heritage was historically transformed into intangible heritage.

Subproject 2: Communal Singing and the Mobilization of Music as Resilience Strategies: An Investigation of Intangible Cultural Heritage in Israel (Prof. Sarah M. Ross und Samuel Weigel)

This subproject aims to provide empirical evidence for the significance of intangible Jewish heritage in coping with wars, crises, and disasters in Israel, and to systematically structure this knowledge. In doing so, it contributes to the integration of knowledge on social responsibility and cultural sustainability into heritage strategies. The project also examines the transferability of resilience factors identified in the context of disaster research—particularly those related to natural hazards—to other types of threat scenarios arising from different stressors.

Specifically, the subproject investigates the potential of collective public singing—such as in Shira Betzibur gatherings or Koolulam initiatives—as a tool to support human recovery processes following traumatic events. In this context, particular attention is given to the cross-generational and cross-cultural reach of Israel’s intangible cultural heritage.

Subproject 2 focuses on exploring the sustainability of musical practices and their impact on social resilience, especially in the aftermath of the Hamas attack on October 7, 2023. Following such profound events, communities often rediscover the potential of intangible heritage, allowing for the emergence of new cultural and musical practices that promote societal healing and recovery. In times of societal upheaval, intangible heritage can act as a stabilizing force that fosters social cohesion.

The overarching goal of the subproject is to develop a deeper understanding of the dual function and dynamic role of music—as both cultural heritage and a means of social empowerment in times of crisis. To achieve this, the project integrates insights from various disciplines—including Jewish Music Studies, Ethnomusicology, and Critical Heritage Studies—as well as findings from Subprojects 1 and 3, thereby constructing a comprehensive picture of the significance of cultural heritage for resilience and cultural sustainability.

Subproject 3: The Relationship Between Disasters, Resilience, and Cultural Heritage in Israel (Dr. Cordula Dittmer und Dr. Daniel F. Lorenz)

The project analyzes the embedding of Jewish cultural heritage in protection practices by institutions responsible for the protection of cultural property, such as civil protection, using a disaster sociological perspective. Cultural heritage does not exist in isolation from questions of societal survival. Rather, practices of ensuring survival are passed on and as such can become part of cultural heritage, even if they are no longer recognizable prima facie. The consideration of cultural heritage in disaster (risk) management is a more recent development and is also part of the process surrounding the UN Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction 2015-2030 (SFDRR). It is not only “positive” cultural heritage that is classified as worthy of preservation, as is the case when considering intangible cultural heritage – usually defined as local knowledge. Cultural heritage can also include the memory of negative experiences, such as disasters or genocides, if these play a special role in identity. This is also referred to as dark heritage. Cultural heritage therefore plays a decisive role in the development of social resilience and in coping with disasters and crises. The qualitative empirical study investigates how the protection of Jewish cultural heritage is perceived and socially constructed by the responsible actors of Israeli civil defense and disaster control and which practices for the protection of cultural heritage can be derived from this for other regions.

more…

Bibliography

Dittmer, C.; Lorenz, D.F. 2018: Forschen im Kontext von Vulnerabilität und extremem Leid – Ethische Fragen der sozialwissenschaftlichen Katastrophenforschung. FQS 19, Nr. 3, Art. 20. DOI: 10.17169/fqs-19.3.3116.

Dittmer, C.; Lorenz, D.F. 2021. Disaster Situation and Humanitarian Emergency – In-Between Responses to the Refugee Crisis in Germany. In: International Migration 59: 96–112. DOI:10.1111/imig.12679.

Dittmer, C.; Lorenz, D.F. 2024. Emergent, Extending, Expanding and Established Citizen Disaster Response in the German Ahr valley Flood in 2021. In: IJDRR, 105, 104394. DOI: 10.1016/j.ijdrr.2024.104394.

Dittmer, C.; Voss, M. 2025. Societal resilience in Germany: Conceptual and empirical reflections for dealing with crises and disasters. In: Stępka, M.; Mazurkiewicz, A.; Krüger, M.: Emerging Varieties of Resilience. Experiences from Germany, Poland and Ukraine. Routledge, S. 36-53. DOI: 10.4324/9781003503255-3

Hutter, Gérard; Lorenz, Daniel F. (2018): Social Resilience. In: Fuchs, Sven; Thaler, Thomas (Hg.): Vulnerability and Resilience. Cambridge, Großbritannien, S. 190-213.

Keßler, Katrin; Ross, Sarah M.; Staudinger, Barbara und Weik, Lea, Hrg. und Mitautorinnen (2022): Jewish Life and Culture in Germany after 1945. Sacred Spaces, Objects and Musical Traditions. Berlin: De Gruyter.

Kranz, Dani und Ross, Sarah M. (2022): Jüdische Selbstermächtigung in der deutschen Wissenschaftslandschaft. Tektonische Verschiebungen in der Judaistik und den Jüdischen Studien nach 1990. In: Marina Chernivsky und Friederike Lorenz (Hg.), Die Shoah in Bildung und Erziehungs. Weitergaben und Wirkungen in Gegenwartsverhältnissen. Leverkusen: Verlag Barbara Budrich, 79-100.

Lorenz, D.F. 2013. „The Diversity of Resilience. Contributions from Social Science Perspective“. Natural Hazards 67: 7-24. DOI:10.1007/s11069-010-9654-y.

Lorenz, D.F.; Dittmer, C. 2016. „Resilience in Catastrophes, Disasters and Emergencies. Socio-scientific Perspectives.” In A. Mauerer (Hg.) New Perspectives on Resilience in Socio-Economic Spheres, 25-59. Heidelberg: Springer.

Ross, Sarah M. (2022): Jewish Musical Heritage in Post-War Germany. Negotiating Jewish Self-Understanding through Synagogue Chant. In: Katrin Keßler, Sarah Ross, Barbara Staudinger und Leah Weik (Hg.), Jewish Life and Culture in Germany after 1945. Sacred Spaces, Objects and Musical Traditions. Berlin: De Gruyter, 189-210. Online verfügbar unter https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110750812-013.

Ross, Sarah M. (2024): The Moralization of Jewish Heritage in Germany. Sustaining Jewish Life in Twenty-First Century, Lanham, Maryland: Lexington Books.

Ross, Sarah M., Hg. und Mitautorin (2021): Jüdisches Kulturerbe MUSIK – Divergenzen und Zeitlichkeit. Überlegungen zu einer kulturellen Nachhaltigkeit aus Sicht der Jüdischen Musikstudien. Bern: Peter Lang.

Ross, Sarah M.; Kranz, Dani (2023): „Jüdisches Kulturerbe“ versus „Jewish heritage“. Zum gesellschaftspolitischen Stellenwert von jüdischem Erbe in Deutschland. Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung. Online verfügbar unter https://www.bpb.de/themen/zeit-kulturgeschichte/juedischesleben/515818/juedisches-kulturerbe-versus-jewish-heritage/.

Weigel, Samuel (2022): Introduction to Part 3: Community, Religious Practice and Synagogue Music in Post-War Germany. In: Katrin Keßler, Sarah Ross, Barbara Staudinger und Leah Weik (Hg.), Jewish Life and Culture in Germany after 1945. Sacred Spaces, Objects and Musical Traditions. Berlin: De Gruyter, 165-173. Online verfügbar unter https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110750812-011.

Navigation

Last updated on July 28, 2025

Back to top